President’s Council of Advisors on Science and Technology

January 23, 2025

Presidential Actions

View Original

Action Summary

Purpose and Rationale: Emphasizes the historical American spirit of innovation and positions transformative technologies—such as artificial intelligence, quantum computing, and advanced biotechnology—as critical to maintaining U.S. global technological dominance and national security.
Challenges to Scientific Integrity: Highlights concerns over ideological pressures that can distort truth, impede research integrity, and stifle innovation, undermining America’s competitive edge in science and technology.
Establishment of the Council: Creates the President’s Council of Advisors on Science and Technology (PCAST) composed of up to 24 members, including key government advisors and non-Federal experts from academia, industry, and other sectors.
Governance Structure: Designates the Assistant to the President for Science and Technology and the Special Advisor for AI & Crypto as Co-Chairs, with the option for vice chairs from non-Federal members to support leadership and organizational duties.
Core Functions: Instructs the PCAST to advise the President on policies regarding science, technology, education, innovation, national security, and economic implications. The Council will also provide coordination for existing advisory roles related to high-performance computing and nanotechnology research.
Operational Details: Outlines procedures for regular meetings, the creation of subcommittees and ad hoc technical groups, and access to classified information under established security clearance protocols.
Administrative Support and Compensation: Specifies that the Department of Energy will provide funding and support as allowed by law, while members serve without compensation except for authorized travel expenses.
Term and Revocation: Establishes a two-year term for the Council, with the possibility of extension, and revokes previous executive orders related to PCAST.
General Provisions: Clarifies that the order does not affect existing statutory authorities or rights and must be implemented in accordance with applicable law and budgetary provisions.

Risks & Considerations

The establishment of the President’s Council of Advisors on Science and Technology (PCAST) emphasizes the importance of maintaining technological dominance, which could lead to increased federal focus and funding on research and development in transformative technologies such as AI, quantum computing, and biotechnology. This may create opportunities for Vanderbilt University to engage in cutting-edge research and secure federal grants.
The order highlights the threat of ideological dogmas in science, which could influence the direction of research funding and priorities. Vanderbilt may need to ensure that its research initiatives align with federal priorities to remain competitive in securing funding.
The PCAST’s role in advising on science and technology policy could impact national research agendas, potentially affecting the focus areas of university research programs. Vanderbilt may need to adapt its strategic research priorities to align with national interests.
As the PCAST will solicit information from a broad range of stakeholders, including universities, Vanderbilt has the opportunity to contribute to national policy discussions, potentially influencing the direction of science and technology policy.

Impacted Programs

Vanderbilt’s School of Engineering and College of Arts and Science may benefit from increased opportunities for collaboration and funding in areas such as AI, quantum computing, and biotechnology.
The Office of Federal Relations at Vanderbilt could play a crucial role in engaging with the PCAST and other federal agencies to advocate for the university’s research interests and priorities.
Vanderbilt’s Research Centers focused on technology and innovation may see increased demand for their expertise and potential partnerships with federal agencies and industry leaders.

Financial Impact

The focus on technological dominance and innovation could lead to increased federal funding opportunities for research institutions. Vanderbilt may need to strategically position itself to take advantage of these opportunities.
Changes in national research priorities could affect the allocation of federal research grants, necessitating adjustments in Vanderbilt’s grant application strategies and research focus areas.
Vanderbilt may experience increased competition for federal funding as other institutions also seek to align with national priorities and secure grants in high-impact research areas.

Relevance Score: 3 (The order presents moderate risks involving compliance and alignment with national research priorities.)

Key Actions

Vanderbilt’s School of Engineering should engage with the President’s Council of Advisors on Science and Technology (PCAST) to contribute expertise in artificial intelligence, quantum computing, and biotechnology. This engagement can help shape national policies and ensure that Vanderbilt remains at the forefront of technological innovation.
The Office of Federal Relations should monitor developments and recommendations from PCAST to identify potential funding opportunities and collaborations with federal agencies, particularly in areas related to advanced technology and innovation.
Vanderbilt’s Research Centers should prepare to align their strategic goals with the national emphasis on maintaining global technological dominance. This may involve prioritizing research initiatives that align with national security and economic competitiveness.
The Department of Political Science should analyze the implications of the executive order on national and global policy, providing insights that can inform Vanderbilt’s strategic positioning in science and technology.

Opportunities

The establishment of PCAST presents an opportunity for Vanderbilt University to enhance its role as a leader in science and technology by participating in national discussions and contributing to policy development.
By leveraging its diverse expertise, Vanderbilt can position itself as a key partner in federal initiatives aimed at advancing technological innovation and addressing national security challenges.
The focus on empowering entrepreneurs and reinvigorating research institutions aligns with Vanderbilt’s mission, offering opportunities to expand partnerships with industry and government to drive innovation.

Relevance Score: 4 (The order necessitates major process changes to align with national priorities in science and technology, impacting Vanderbilt’s strategic initiatives.)

Average Relevance Score: 3

Timeline for Implementation

The President’s Council of Advisors on Science and Technology shall terminate 2 years from January 23, 2025 (i.e., by January 23, 2027), unless extended by the President.

Relevance Score: 1

Impacted Government Organizations

President’s Council of Advisors on Science and Technology (PCAST): Established by this order, PCAST is the central advisory body providing guidance on science and technology policy.
Office of Science and Technology Policy (OSTP): Implicated through the dual role of the Assistant to the President for Science and Technology, who, if also serving as Director of OSTP, may designate the U.S. Chief Technology Officer as a PCAST member.
Department of Energy (DOE): Tasked with providing funding, administrative, and technical support to PCAST as required under this order.
National Science and Technology Council (NSTC): Receives advice from PCAST on measures affecting science, technology, education, and innovation policy.
Heads of Executive Departments and Agencies: Instructed to support PCAST by providing necessary scientific and technological information for its advisory functions.

Relevance Score: 2 (Several key federal organizations and advisory entities are affected by the order.)

Responsible Officials

Assistant to the President for Science and Technology (APST) – Serves as a member and Co‑Chair of the President’s Council of Advisors on Science and Technology (PCAST), guiding its operations and, if applicable, designating the U.S. Chief Technology Officer as a member.
Special Advisor for AI & Crypto – Acts as the Co‑Chair of PCAST alongside the APST, contributing to the council’s leadership and organization.
Heads of Executive Departments and Agencies – Required to provide the PCAST with relevant scientific and technological information when requested by the council’s Co‑Chairs.
Secretary of Energy – Responsible for supplying PCAST’s funding, administrative and technical support, and for performing specific functions under the Federal Advisory Committee Act as directed in this order.

Relevance Score: 5 (Directives affect high-level White House officials and Cabinet agency heads, ensuring strategic, national-level impact.)